The leftovers plan has two halves, and the first one happens on Thursday night: get everything into shallow containers within two hours, carve the turkey off the bone before it goes in the fridge, and bag the carcass for stock. The second half is deciding what becomes what, which is much easier once you know how long each thing actually has.
Most leftovers are not thrown out because nobody wanted them. They are thrown out because nobody was sure, and four days later the answer defaulted to no.
The USDA's general rule for cooked leftovers is about four days in the fridge. More specifically:
| Dish | Fridge | Freezer |
|---|---|---|
| Turkey | 3 to 4 days | 2 to 6 months |
| Gravy | 3 to 4 days | 1 to 2 months |
| Stuffing | 3 to 4 days | about 1 month |
| Mashed potato | 3 to 4 days | freezes well |
| Green bean casserole | 3 to 5 days | 4 to 6 months |
| Mac and cheese | 3 to 5 days | freezes well |
| Ham | 3 to 4 days | 1 to 2 months |
| Cranberry sauce | up to a week | not recommended, goes watery |
The two-hour rule matters more than any of those numbers. Perishable food should not sit at room temperature longer than two hours, and the clock starts when it goes on the table, not when people finish eating. A dish that spent four hours out does not get four days in the fridge.
Shallow containers, not one deep tub. A deep container cools from the outside in and the middle stays warm for hours, which is exactly the condition you are trying to avoid. Spread things out.
Do this before anyone opens a second bottle:
Rather than one leftovers recipe, a rough running order that uses things up in the order they expire.
Friday: the sandwich. This is what everyone wants and nothing else needs to happen. Turkey, cranberry, whatever stuffing survived, good bread. Do not improve it.
Saturday: the hash or the pie. Potatoes and turkey in a frying pan with something crisp, or a pot pie using up the gravy, which is on a shorter clock than the turkey is.
Sunday: the soup. Carcass into a pot with the sad celery and onion ends from Wednesday's prep. This is the best thing to come out of the whole holiday and it costs nothing.
The freezer: whatever is left. Turkey portions, gravy, a tray of the casserole. Labelled, because a bag of unlabelled frozen beige in February is a gamble nobody wins.
Four days of leftovers, planned once on Thursday night.
Putting those four onto the days in a meal plan on Thursday night takes a minute and means nobody opens the fridge on Saturday wondering. It also stops the weekend shop happening out of habit when the fridge is already full.
Tradish is launching on iOS and Android soon. Plan the week the leftovers cover, and keep the recipes you invent out of them. Join the waitlist for early access and our best launch price.
Freezes well: turkey, gravy, stuffing, mashed potato, most casseroles, soup, pie.
Doesn't: cranberry sauce, which goes watery. Roasted vegetables, which turn soft. Anything with a crisp topping that mattered, which will not be crisp again.
For the ones that don't freeze, the move is to use them in something else rather than to store them as themselves. Leftover cranberry sauce is excellent stirred into a vinaigrette or spooned onto cheese on toast. Soft roasted vegetables are already most of the way to a soup.
While you are standing in the kitchen at the end of it, write down what you would change. Whether the bird was done earlier than the timeline said. Whether you ran short on gravy, which everyone always does. Whether four sides was right or one too many.
You will not remember any of this next November. In Tradish, the cook log on a recipe takes a note, a photo and a rating, which is exactly the right home for "started the turkey an hour too early, brilliant, do it again."
The USDA puts cooked leftovers at about four days. Most sides hold three to four, green bean casserole and mac and cheese three to five, and cranberry sauce up to a week. Get everything chilled within two hours of serving.
Most of them. Turkey, gravy and stuffing all freeze, roughly one to two months for gravy and about a month for stuffing. Cranberry sauce is the one to skip, since it goes watery. Potatoes freeze better mashed than roasted.
In shallow containers rather than one deep tub, so they chill quickly all the way through. Carve the turkey off the bone before refrigerating it rather than putting the whole carcass in.
Sandwiches first, because that is what everybody actually wants. Then soup from the carcass, a pie or pot pie, a hash with the potatoes, or anything where the turkey is an ingredient rather than the point.
Yes. It makes far better stock than anything you can buy, and if you have no energy for it on the night, bag it and freeze it whole to deal with another weekend.
Shallow containers, turkey off the bone, carcass bagged, and food sent home with whoever will take it. Then let the week run sandwich, hash, soup, freezer, in roughly that order, because that is the order things expire in.
Tradish is launching on iOS and Android soon. Join the waitlist to be first to know when we launch.
Related reading: